Both the Pickens Plan and the various ideas for creating electric cars have a drawback that I’ve seen few people make notice about.
The lack of range for both natural gas and electric vehicles.
For pure electric vehicles, the current available range is about 50 miles. There’s talk of getting up to 120 miles with future technology.
Natural gas cars right now have a range of about 220-180 miles, depending on who you ask.
Compare this to current technology: gasoline automobiles can generally get about 400 miles per tank, which depends on the vehicle, but that a general range for most cars I’ve seen. Some get more, some get less, but an average of 400 seems about right.
Now, for most people who have taken road trips, it can be a pain in the rear to find gas and fill up. Alot of the time, you end up paying more because you’re not familiar with the area, so you end up buying at a station that may not be the cheapest. There’s also the situation where you end up needing to get gas, and then miss the station down the road that’s a couple of cents cheaper. But if you only need to fuel once, or not at all, then you don’t have these problems to begin with. Plus, there’s the delay of having to stop driving, get out, fuel, then get going again. It’s a hassle.
So a longer range means less of these problems. But that seems to be the last issue on the minds of car developers and those who want to prop up alternative fuels right now. Electric car people tend to focus on commuters. Which is fine, if commuting was the only thing that people did with their cars.
It’s not.
The same problem goes with natural gas. From a link provided by the Pickens Plan:
* Second drawback: since natural gas is a compressed fuel, the tank takes up some trunk space, and only holds the equivalent of 8 gallons of gasoline. Honda estimates the vehicle’s range to be 220 to 250 miles, although Consumer Reports claimed it was closer to 180 miles.
NGV enthusiasts are getting around range limitations (and vehicle scarcity) by converting their own vehicles to run on natural gas and adding spare tank capacity. Throwing extra tanks in the bed of a truck, for example, can boost driving range to around 600 miles. The best part about converting a vehicle (as opposed to the Civic GX) is that if you run out of CNG, the system automatically switches back to gasoline.
– Gas 2.0
Throwing extra tanks in is fine if you’re by yourself and you have room to spare in your trunk. But vacationers don’t have that liberty, especially if they have children. Which means they’ll need bigger cars (oh no, SUVs!) or fill up more frequently.
Finally, there’s the problem of filling up. Now, there is the option of refueling at home for both electricity and natural gas. But what about on the road? Especially in rural areas, there seems to be a dearth of natural gas and electric refueling stations. Now, there’s also a dearth of gas stations in rural areas too, but I’m even talking along highways. You’re going to need alot more stations if the fuel doesn’t get enough range.
And what happens if you run out of gas. Like I mentioned before, there’s the problem of bringing gas out to someone who’s stranded. But what about LNG or electricity. Maybe you can find a house where you can plug your car in, but you’d need a pretty long extension cord. Or maybe drain from someone else’s car, but LNG is a bit more problematic than that.
Nevermind that alot of the cars proposed are compact/sub-compact. Again, a problem for families or people who are of larger than average size. I would like to see what the results for a full-size/truck/SUV are before I can say that electric/natural gas vehicles will have mainstream appeal. And without mainstream appeal, we’re just talking in hypothesis.
It seems to me that alot of the focus on travel seems to be withing larger urban and suburban areas and commuters specifically. Which is fine, except that it neglects a significant aspect of driving for many people. The idea of going somewhere other than work. That something that all proponents of alt fuels will need to grasp and pay attention to as well.
